About Us Our Work Employment News & Events
MITRE Remote Access for MITRE Staff and Partners Site Map
The MITRE Digest

Follow Us:

Visit MITRE on Facebook
Visit MITRE on Twitter
Visit MITRE on Linkedin
Visit MITRE on YouTube
View MITRE's RSS Feeds
View MITRE's Mobile Apps
Home > News & Events > MITRE Publications > The MITRE Digest >
spacer

Nano Lab's Tools Address Government Needs


April 2008

Nano Lab's Tools Address Government Needs

Before the Nanotechnology-Biotechnology Laboratory opened in 2006, MITRE's scientists and engineers had to be content with just doing simulation, modeling, and other theoretical investigations of nanotechnology. Since then, with state-of-the-art laboratory tools, they have been expanding their groundbreaking research to include physical experimentation.

"For 15 years, MITRE has been instrumental in developing systems engineering programs with the government to exploit developments in nanoelectronics," says Carl Picconatto, the Nano Lab's director and lead scientist. "Expanding our efforts beyond modeling and simulation to include physical experimentation was a very natural step, and an important one to position MITRE to better serve our government clients. Over the past two years, we have greatly increased our prototyping and testing capabilities to better assist the government in developing nanosystems."

Today the Nano Lab's projects range from nano-enabled energy systems to the development of "nano-noses" for nose-like sensing. Meanwhile, a companion Biotechnology Lab supports projects in computational biology, analysis of proteins and nucleotides, and rapid diagnosis of biological agents. The co-location of these two labs on MITRE's McLean, Va., campus fosters stronger collaborations between the two disciplines, allowing them to share their equipment and ideas with one another.

The Nanotechnology-Biotechnology Laboratory is the brainchild of James Ellenbogen, senior principal scientist of MITRE's Nanosystems Group. He first proposed such a laboratory in 1997, then in 2003 teamed with Picconatto and MITRE biotechnologists Jordan Feidler and John DiLeo in planning the present combined lab. Though the Nanosystems Group has been performing broad-based research and development in nanotechnology since 1992, Ellenbogen emphasizes that the laboratory has taken this work into a new dimension.

"The Nano Lab is helping MITRE build physical prototypes of integrated nanosystems and test them, as well as just design them," says Ellenbogen. "We're helping the government maintain U.S. technical preeminence in nanotechnology by harnessing innovations in basic science and technology in order to engineer them into very dense—and sometimes very tiny—extended systems integrated on the nanometer scale."

Latest Research Tools

The Nano Lab's equipment would light up the eyes of any nanotechnology researcher who likes to push atoms and molecules around. First of all, there's a scanning probe microscope that uses atomic force microscope (AFM) methods for surface characterization of properties like topography, elasticity, friction, adhesion, and electrical/magnetic fields. It also uses a scanning tunneling mode to acquire data for images at the atomic scale (see sidebar). For fabricating components, there is a high-precision wire bonder and an electrostatic discharge-safe packaging and component assembly unit. A state-of-the-art electronic probe station and a suite of electronics equipment permit detailed measurement and characterization.

Carl Picconatto and summer intern Julian McMorrow use MITRE's scanning probe microscope to make measurements on the atomic and molecular scale. The inset is an image of a graphite surface and shows individual carbon atoms that make up the graphite lattice.

Carl Picconatto and summer intern Julian McMorrow use MITRE's scanning probe microscope to make measurements on the atomic and molecular scale. The inset is an image of a graphite surface and shows individual carbon atoms that make up the graphite lattice.

Picconatto points out that the facility also has a fully functioning chemistry lab, including a gas chromatograph/mass spectrometer. Chromatography separates compounds by chemical activity, while mass spectrometry determines each compound's identity. "It can do anything a state-of-the-art chemistry facility can do, and we're using it in conjunction with our electronics efforts for the government," he says.

Sniffing Out the Bad Guys

Most of the work in the Nano Lab is centered on four experimental focus areas that are of particular interest to MITRE's government clients. In one of these areas, the lab is conducting prototyping and testing on nano-enabled sensor systems. This also involves research on odorants, especially their role in biometric identification. Nanosystems group leader Brigitte Rolfe leads this effort, working toward the integration of nanosensors into nose-like electronic systems.

Electronic sensors that detect odors aren't new. They're used in the perfume industry for quality control, in industrial settings to monitor the emission of noxious gases, and even in common appliances to detect leaks or other malfunctions. The artificial noses that currently exist in the commercial world are about the size of a credit card and contain approximately 20 individual sensors. However, to come close to working as well as natural noses, you need millions and millions of sensors working together as a system. That means shrinking the individual sensors down to the nanoscale. Fortunately, development of nanoscale electronic sensors has blossomed in recent years. "MITRE is using a systems engineering approach to integrate these discoveries into extended systems for more truly nose-like sensing," says Rolfe.

Carbon Nanotube Separation

Another focus area in the Nano Lab is the development of nanomaterials, and, in particular, the development of carbon nanotube (CNT) separation techniques. CNTs have unprecedented physical and electrical properties, but unfortunately they can be produced only in mixtures of different types that exhibit a wide range of electrical behaviors, from metal to semiconductor. That's a big problem for electronics applications, since metal nanotubes produce short circuits.

Carbon nanotubes (white areas) are orientated according to their chirality after being deposited on a sheet of graphite. Black lines are added to the image to make clearer the orientations of the nanotubes.

Carbon nanotubes (white areas) are orientated according to their chirality after being deposited on a sheet of graphite. Black lines are added to the image to make clearer the orientations of the nanotubes.

About eight years ago, MITRE researchers decided to try to separate CNTs rather than focus on how to make a single type. "We hold two patents on potential separation processes and continue to refine them," says Picconatto. The patents are based on the CNTs' intrinsic property of chirality (pronounced ky-rality), or handedness. An object is chiral if it is not interchangeable with its mirror image—similar to how your right and left hands are reflections of one another, but are not the same. Chirality in CNTs is exhibited by a twist in their structure along their length. This twist can be expressed as an angle or by two index numbers. Small differences in chirality can produce radically different behaviors. For example, a (12, 0) tube is a metal but a (12, 1) tube is a semiconductor.

"Finding a way to mass produce CNTs of a single chirality has been called the 'holy grail' of nanotech," Picconatto says. "Industry has worked for over 10 years trying to make batches of nanotubes of only a single type at a time, but hasn't been successful."

Calculations done by MITRE and its collaborators suggest that CNTs with different chiral angles should orient differently on certain surfaces. Further, the energy differences of these orientations are much greater than expected and could form the basis of a separation technique. "When the nanotubes deposit on a graphite substrate, they want to orient themselves at specific angles to the atomic lattice of the graphite," he says. "The angle depends on the chirality. We're trying to develop this effect into a viable bulk separation process."

Nano-Enabled Power Systems

The Nano Lab's third focus area is nano-enabled power systems. "We're doing independent verification and validation on new nano-enabled energy storage devices and power-delivery devices," Picconatto says. "The government needs to confirm the performance of these devices for use in traditional acquisition programs like communications systems or smart munitions." To meet such needs, the Nano Lab has built testbeds for nano-enabled batteries and nano-enabled supercapacitors.

"We're also developing prototype hybrid power delivery systems that combine the high-energy density of batteries with the high-power density of supercapacitors," he continues. "Such a system would use a nano-enabled, high-energy battery to meet its average energy needs, but switch to a high-power supercapacitor for an instantaneous boost when a large power drain is required. While there are some R&D challenges with each type of subsystem, this is largely a systems integration problem where we are trying to build an effective hybrid system that combines high-energy batteries with supercapacitors to get power profiles that fit specific applications."

Nanoelectronics R&D

The Nano Lab's fourth focus area involves the development of nanoelectronic systems for specialized applications. This path expands upon MITRE's original nanotechnology focus of designing ultra-dense electronic systems. Also, it embraces a project that began several years ago to develop a six-legged millimeter-scale robot in order to study the integration of micromachines and nanoelectronics. Fabrication and prototyping of that system continues, but now this focus area also develops special-purpose nanoelectronics for next-generation military systems. Along with those efforts, the lab has a suite of equipment for testing and measurement of these prototype nanosystems.

MITRE's government clients clearly appreciate the Nano Lab's work. When the lab opened, it had no direct support, only internal funding. Now customer support is three times the amount the company invests. As the lab's reputation grows along with its work program, Picconatto is committed to making sure the lab's capabilities meet the government's needs. One client even purchased an additional piece of equipment for the lab's semiconductor parameter analyzer so that MITRE could perform the specific measurement the client wanted.

"It was the first time we had a major piece of R&D equipment purchased directly for our laboratory," says Picconatto. "MITRE's targeted development in state-of-the-art infrastructure allowed the government to make a relatively small investment to customize our lab for its needs. Our original lab equipment acquisitions were designed with this in mind, and we've included this concept as an element of our multi-year plan for future lab development."


Scanning Probe Microscope: A View into the Unseeable

The MITRE Nano Lab uses a scanning probe microscope (SPM) to explore matter on the nanometer scale. It has two primary capabilities: as a scanning tunneling microscope (STM) and an atomic force microscope (AFM). The STM uses a tunneling current, which starts to flow when a tiny tip—only a molecule or two wide—approaches and follows the contour of a conducting surface at a distance of a few nanometers. The tip is mounted on a piezoelectric tube, which allows minute movements by applying a voltage to its electrodes. This movement over the underlying surface is recorded and can be displayed as an image of the surface topography.

The AFM moves a cantilever beam with an equally tiny tip at its end over the sample's surface. As the tip is repelled by or attracted to the surface, the end of the cantilever beam moves up or down. A laser beam is directed to the end of the cantilever as it moves up and down and reflects back to a light sensor. The amount of movement detected by the light sensor is converted into an image that shows the hills and valleys of the sample surface. The AFM can work with the tip touching the sample (contact mode), or tapping across the surface (tapping mode).

"The STM is more sensitive," says Picconatto, "You can get down to atomic resolution. With an AFM it's much harder. To get such fine resolution, you would have to work in a vacuum and take a lot of effort to eliminate any vibrations."

—by David A. Van Cleave


Related Information

Articles and News

Technical Papers and Presentations

Websites

 

Page last updated: April 17, 2008 | Top of page

Homeland Security Center Center for Enterprise Modernization Command, Control, Communications and Intelligence Center Center for Advanced Aviation System Development

 
 
 

Solutions That Make a Difference.®
Copyright © 1997-2013, The MITRE Corporation. All rights reserved.
MITRE is a registered trademark of The MITRE Corporation.
Material on this site may be copied and distributed with permission only.

IDG's Computerworld Names MITRE a "Best Place to Work in IT" for Eighth Straight Year The Boston Globe Ranks MITRE Number 6 Top Place to Work Fast Company Names MITRE One of the "World's 50 Most Innovative Companies"
 

Privacy Policy | Contact Us